Sunday, May 11, 2025


































































Young Voice in Animal/Environmental Ethics: Adhyaan Balaji


“Meat is Murder”
             By Adhyaan Balaji

In the cut and thrust of talk about food, one principle of veganism stands supreme—meat is undoubtedly murder. However, veganism doesn’t stop there. Even products like cheese, which most people can’t live without, are made from milk, the nutritious sustenance meant for a mother to give her newborn calf. So many throughout the world claim to love animals truly, but if this is the deeper and darker truth behind the diets of 72% of the world’s population (the percentage of individuals who eat both meat and animal products), why don’t we stop the consumption of animal products for good? What if we all pulled our forks and knives out of our steaks and became vegan? What if we found our reason to say no to a juicy burger, a fluffy omelet, or a cheesy pizza?

Once considered to be a radical dietary choice, veganism has become increasingly mainstream throughout the world, providing benefits not only to our health but also to the planet. More than a quarter of all greenhouse gas emissions can be traced back to animal food. Cows bear the biggest responsibility, leaving an annual carbon footprint equivalent to CO₂ emissions from every train, ship, car, and aircraft. Now, of course, the large majority of us don’t immediately think of cows as a catalyst for global warming. Still, as it turns out, the one and a half billion cows in the world produce 150 kilograms of methane on average per year, a compound that, concerning the negative effects of CO₂ on climate change, proves to be 23 times worse. Additionally, about two-thirds of all the agricultural land on the planet is occupied by cattle alone. If everyone were to go vegan, we would use most of this pasture land to restore forests and grasslands to reduce the level of CO₂ in the air. We could start harvesting more crops to help fill the hotels in our food supply. Additionally, livestock-related greenhouse gas emissions would drop by nearly 70%. Veganism is often argued to be for the animals, but also ‘for the people’ but the outlook after a global conversion to veganism isn’t all sunshine and rainbows. Veganism represents a sustainable option for feeding a family and slows down the global heating process of our planet. It’s often described as a way for the poorest people in our world, who often fall ill from the lack of quality in meats and animal products that they consume. However, it’s these more impoverished rural areas that would be hit the hardest. Your local butcher, as well as millions of farmers worldwide, would suddenly be jobless. They could try to grow and supply us with more crops, but on a larger scale, rural communities that were once able to provide people with milk, eggs, and meat would face severe amounts of unemployment. Jobs that were once the very core of our societies satience would vanish overnight.

This doesn’t just end on a local scale. What about society as a whole? Dozens of countries worldwide, dependent on agribusiness and animal-related commodities as exports, would face huge economic disruption as the demand for something as simple as a glass of milk would be next to zero. The dependence on a single animal-based commodity for these developing countries would completely halt the progress of their society. On the bright side, though, everybody would be a little bit healthier, but would we? Despite the ongoing slur of potential benefits that a vegan diet may offer, some of which include lowering the risk of certain cancers and heart diseases, and almost eliminating the probability of type 2 diabetes, vegans often miss out on several important nutrients. Calcium and especially vitamin B12, both present in milk, would be incredibly hard to come by. And while the Omega 3 fatty acids from salmon could be substituted with walnuts, shortcuts like this could actually lead to weight gain as walnuts, despite being a good source of Omega 3 for vegetarians, are also known to be incredibly calorie-dense. Due to various animal meats no longer being available as a source of complete protein, vegans would have to mix and match various foods such as soy, beans, and lentils in order to ensure they receive all the necessary amino acids for proper bodily function. However, with a proper diet, we as a population could celebrate lower levels of obesity and lower global mortality rates. This would contribute to nearly 1 trillion dollars saved on healthcare and more than 8 million saved lives.

A global shift from one diet to another wouldn’t just impact the health of billions of people around the world, it would cause global shifts in the economy, profound changes in the job market, fluctuations in national economies, and greatly impact the healthcare sector. While making the switch from our current eating habits to veganism, we would undoubtably benefit from the healthier living and surplus of energy, so long as we maintain a diet enriched with the proper nutrients. On top of our health, we would be creating a healthier planet for the future of humankind. We wouldn’t need animal products to satiate ourselves any longer, after all meat is murder. But the consequences would be catastrophic for the monumental developments that we as people have been able to bring the world thus far. Economies all across the globe would be in shambles and global trade would see drastic changes. Millions of people all over the world would become jobless overnight, and poverty-stricken communities would become increasingly poorer. The farm animals would be safe though. Except for the estimated 20 billion chickens who have, since their early days of living in the wild, evolved too far to ever be able to live outside of human care. Even animals such as horses and goats who seem to be much more capable of the rugged wilderness would be preyed on as most of these animals were bred in captivity making it difficult to transition back into the wild. Of course, there are good arguments for both sides, but it really begs the question—does meat truly mean murder? Or is meat what moves humankind?

- Adhyaan Balaji is a budding writer and rising high school junior with a profound passion for sports, medicine, and dietetics. As a semi-professional student athlete and a nationally ranked badminton player, he understands nutrition and health’s critical role in promoting efficiency and performance in all aspects of life. His interest in optimizing physical and mental potential stemming from his pursuits in junior professional sports has led him to explore plant-based nutrition and its role in fulfilling the nutritional standards of animal products and its implications on endurance, recovery, and long-term well-being. He considers sport, nutrition, and healthcare as disciplines with interconnected principles that work to shape the way the body can perform at its highest level.

Copyright©2025 by Adhyaan Balaji. All Rights Reserved. Image by Asompoch from Pixabay.